KloraneKlorane Floral Lotion Eye Make-up Remover

BUY at Birchbox

We've been trying to hunt down the perfect eye makeup remover for ages: some are too oily, while others sting our sensitive eyes. That's why we couldn't be happier about discovering this pH-balanced formula (read: it's gentle) from a cult French brand. A day's worth of mascara comes off no prob, and it's suitable for even the most delicate skin.